E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin)

Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review

Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin

characters Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin review Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin 107 Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder S los ue van desde 1933 a 1945El presente estudio implica aspectos militares políticos económicos sociales culturales e intelectuales y se basa en la extensa documentación aparecida con la apertura de los archivos de la Europa oriental y los testimonios de las víctimas y de algunos verdugosLas Tierras de sangre no son un territorio político real o imaginario son simplemente los lugares donde los regímenes políticos de Europa realizaron su obra más mortífer. The history told in Timothy Snyder s Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin is not a revelation Readers familiar with the works of Robert Conuest Daniel Goldhagen Anne Applebaum or Halik Kochanski have read it all before Snyder presents it with a new perspective concentrating on the plight of the minority peoples caught between the two ideological empires of the mid twentieth century Ukrainians Belorussians Balts Roma Russians Germans Poles Jews all pawns of Hitler and Stalin Both tyrants were committed to ethnic and cultural homogeneity in the lands they ruled but as Snyder so aptly pointed out it was Stalin who won Hitler s war so his vision triumphedThe old adage about man s inhumanity to man was never reinforced better than in Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin While well written often captivating and thoroughly footnoted extensive references in English Polish German and Russian it is undeniably a depressing book Stalinism with its forced collectivization of agriculture the liuidation of the kulaks as a class and recurring politically driven suppressions when married in time and geography with Nazism s bloodlust and pseudo scientific racism resulted in a clash of unrivaled barbarity The beleaguered peoples of Eastern Europe bore the brunt A volatile mix of nationalism racism and political ideology led to the devastation of wide swaths of the European borderlands where mixed religions ethnicities and cultures had survived and even thrived during the ages of the Habsburgs Hohenzollerns and Romanovs The advent of Hitler and Stalin ended that situation perhaps forever The numbers are mind boggling Many millions were slaughtered and no group escaped untouched In Warsaw on 5 and 6 August 1944 alone SS Special Commando Dirlewanger shot 40000 Polish civilians While much of western historiography has been focused on the Holocaust the Jews comprised 540 million of the 14 million victims of totalitarianism in the bloodlands Snyder rounds out the ugly tale of murder Timothy Snyder deserves great credit for presenting a new look at this sanguinary chapter of European history So much of today s news on the region has been shaped by the events described and explained in Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin Snyder s book earned a rating of Four Stars in my library Another plus The text is accompanied by excellent maps A brief study of the maps reflecting the changing borders in the region from 1918 through the post war era is in itself enlightening

characters Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin

characters Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin review Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin 107 Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder Mo nunca vio un campo de concentración ni de exterminioDel mismo modo los asesinatos en masa en Europa suelen asociarse con la muerte en cámaras de gas Pero no fue el gas el método más empleado Más de siete millones de civiles y prisioneros de guerra murieron porue se les negó la comida Por primera vez el historiador Timothy Snyder describe en este libro la amplitud del horror ue supuso el asesinato de catorce millones de ciudadanos europeos en solo doce año. Timothy Snyder s Bloodlands is about the worst place that ever existed in the world that unfortunate slice of Europe ruled by the two evilest people who ever inhabited our earth Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin Imagine a Venn diagram of evil The left west loop is Hitler the right east loop in Stalin And in the middle where the two circles overlap is the bloodlands extending from central Poland to western Russia through Ukraine Belarus and the Baltic States From 1933 to 1945 14 million people died in this ill fated swatch of ground Bloodlands is their story Snyder begins with the famines in Soviet Ukraine brought about by the collectivization reuired by Stalin s five year plan This initial chapter is a bit on the frustrating side Like many who came of age watching Saving Private Ryan I m a World War II junkie There are books on my shelf emblazoned with swastikas than I care to admit That doesn t make me knowledgeable on the subject however Indeed my reading has always tended to be a bit myopic I ve read ten books on the D Day landings at Normandy to every one book on the decade leading up to war That s even true with regards to the USSR about which I frankly know next to nothing Accordingly I could have used a little table setting a little explanation of why things were they way they were Snyder though simply jumps right inDespite this this first chapter is among the most memorable and sets the tone for the rest of the book Most histories take a top down approach They start with the big picture the big events and the big people Occasionally they will zoom in for a detailed glimpse showing us what it was like for the common man but this is only done for color Snyder inverts this usual approach He takes a microscopic bottom up approach that begins and ends with the human dimension as its main focus I don t mean to say that Snyder ignores Hitler or Stalin or any of their henchmen He doesn t In fact he spends as much time with them as any other World War II book But Snyder does such a good job of integrating elouent searing first hand accounts into his narrative that it leaves a lasting impression He never forgets that history is not a relic to be studied it is the story of human beings This is never apparent than in Snyder s dealing with the famines The death toll of the World War II era defy comprehension At the very least though through archival footage photographs and film we can start to imagine what the Holocaust was like Starvation though is another matter In comparison to marching someone to the gas chamber it seems like a crime of omission Snyder forces you to reconsider to envision what it actually means to starve to death on a large scale and on a personal level The Ukrainian musician Yosyp Panasenko was dispatched by central authorities with his troupe of bandura players to provide culture to the starving peasants Even as the state took the peasants last bit of food it had the grotesue inclination to elevate the minds and rouse the spirits of the dying The musicians found village after village completely abandoned Then they finally came across some people two girls dead in a bed two legs of a man protruding from a stove and an old lady raving and running her fingernails through the dirtFrom the Ukrainian famines Bloodlands moves into familiar territory Stalin s Great Terror the Nazi dispossession of the Jews the einsatzgruppen aktions in the east following Operation Barbarossa and Hitler s invasion of the Soviet Union and of course the Nazi concentration camps some of which killed directly and others of which worked through attrition There are also sections devoted to Stalin s treatment of the Jews as well as resistance movements especially the two uprisings in Warsaw Snyder covers this territory with empathy that is rare in history books He has a plain unadorned writing style that is appropriate to the subject matter His keen eye for detail and acknowledgement of the power of certain simple facts makes for poignant reading He should also be commended for his refusal to engage in simplistic comparisons pitting Hitler s fascism verses Stalin s communism Any discussion about who was worse is at its core idiotic They both sucked than anything else on this planet has ever sucked Undoubtedly the subject matter of Bloodlands is grim And really you should expect that since the name of the book is Bloodlands Yet the book itself is livened by Snyder s injection of humanity A contemporary of the late writer and intellectual Tony Judt with whom Snyder collaborated Snyder is than an able historian devoted to uncovering all the primary sources in all their many languages He is also a thinker All good histories tell you what happened Snyder tries to work on two levels simultaneously by also attempting an explanation at what it means todayHere perhaps is a purpose for history somewhere between the record of death and its constant reinterpretation Only a history of mass killing can unite the numbers and the memories Without history the memories become private which today means national and the numbers become public which is to say an instrument in the international competition for martyrdom Memory is mine and I have the right to do with it as I please numbers are objective and you must accept my counts whether you like them or not Such reasoning allows a nationalist to hug himself with one arm and strike his neighbor with the other

Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder

characters Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin review Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin 107 Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder Es sabido ue la Alemania nazi asesinó cerca de seis millones de judíos Lo ue no lo es tanto es ue junto al horror del Holocausto los regímenes de Hitler y de Stalin asesinaron a otros ocho millones de civiles la mayoría mujeres niños y ancianos solo en lo ue Timothy Snyder denomina las «Tierras de Sangre»Se suele identificar el horror del siglo xx con los campos de concentración Sin embargo la mayoría de las víctimas del nacionalsocialismo y del estalinis. I was raised amongst survivors of the great horror that was the War in Eastern Europe My mother endured forced labour under the Soviets in 1940 and slave labour under the Nazis after 1941 She saw some of her family being deported by the Soviets to almost certain death in Kazakhstan and discovered the rest in a mass grave shot by the Nazis Her best friend survived Auschwitz My Godfather was a partizan in the forests around Lwow fighting both Nazis and Soviets My Godmother lived through the Stalinist regime survived the battles for Kharkov and slave labour in Germany I was taught chess by a White Russian whose memories of that time were horrific Even I visited Auschwitz in 1963 when I returned to England I was shocked to realise non of the English people I knew knew anything about the place Until recently who apart from the Poles knew the truth about KatynSo when I started reading Timothy Snyder s Bloodlands my first impression was There is nothing new here I d heard it all in one place or another But what Snyder does do is take all those evils and puts them together in his Pandora s Box only one thing is missing Hope Because there was no hope only fear and death The depressing bleakness hollows out the soul One has to pause to take stock to look away to absorb the evil and hear the dead cry out for justice and an understanding that what happened there on the Eastern Front in the Bloodlands actually exceeded anything the West could understand The American and British soldiers who liberated the dying inmates from camps in Germany believed that they had discovered the horrors of Nazism The images their photographers and cameramen captured of the corpses and the living skeletons at Bergen Belsen and Buchenwald seemed to convey the worst crimes of Hitlerthis was far from the truth The worst was in the ruins of Warsaw or the fields of Treblinka or the marshes of Belarus or the pits of Babi Yar Timothy Snyder is the conscience of us allSnyder fills his Pandora s Box and then he reveals its contents to us He deals with the real terrors of Stalinism the tragedy of the Great Famine of the Ukraine the nightmare of the Great Terror and the cold blooded elimination of the educated classes and all forms of potential resistance in Poland He goes on to deal with Nazism once the elimination of educated Poles the attempts to depopulate Belarus and the Final Solution He looks at Post War Cold War anti Semitism in a very knowledgeable manner that makes the era clearly understandable He does a wonderful job of sorting the truth out from the false history we have in the West by reminding us for example that by the time the gas chamber and crematoria complexes came on line in spring 1943 than three uarters of the Jews who would be killed in the Holocaust were already dead The name of Belzec is less well known than that of Auschwitz because it was a death camp those who survived it were highly lucky and could be counted on the fingers of one hand The vast majority of Jews killed in the Holocaust never saw a concentration camp Snyder debunks the modern attempts to balance out history the Nazis and the Soviets were not inhuman beasts they were ordinary men and women like you and me These men and women had ideals which they tried to live up to They saw themselves as victims of other groups and their actions were a form of self defense They forced others to collude in their plans by giving them a choice between that or death He reminds us of the real atrocities carried out in the war for example About as many Poles were killed in the bombing of Warsaw in 1939 as Germans were killed in the bombing of Dresden in 1945 For Poles that bombing was just the beginning of one of the bloodiest occupations of the war and that German journalists and some historians have exaggerated the number of Germans killed during wartime and postwar evacuation flight or deportation Snyder s Bloodlands are for me the lands of the old Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth partitioned between 1772 and 1794 The horrors that took place here are just a continuation of the policies of the Germans and Russians to control those lands Perhaps I fall into that category of historians who try to understand the horrors in nationalistic terms he debunks the Russian myth of the Great Patriotic war and points out that most of the Russian dead were Soviet and came from Belarus the Ukraine and Eastern Poland themselves victims of Stalinism in 1939 and earlierI said there was nothing new here that isn t completely true Snyder s research is so broad as he brings the strands together that there will always be a fact that will surprise you no matter how much you think you know the history I never knew that the invading Germans in 1939 tended not to treat captured Polish soldiers as prisoners of war but simply shot many of them as they surrendered Snyder filled his history with facts and figures throughout One simple fact stands in for so many in the book On any given day in the second half of 1941 the Germans shot Jews than had been killed by pogroms in the entire history of the Russian Empire There s nothing new in this book The story and the facts have always been available In this post Cold war era the truth about what went on in the East has been slowly revealed to the West all the false history is been revealed as another version of the West s anti Communist propaganda a Big brother version of history in which Polish troops for example were not allowed to partake in VE celebrations because the country was Communist albeit sold out by the allies at Yalta Snyder brings the true history of this era to the attention of the West Everyone should read it but then I would say that wouldn t I I was raised amongst survivors of the great horror that was the War in Eastern Europe


10 thoughts on “E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin)

  1. says: Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin)

    E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder I was raised amongst survivors of the great horror that was the War in Eastern Europe My mother endured forced labour under

  2. says: Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review

    Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Man Oh manThis book is without a doubt the most depressing thing I've ever read If there was ever a time and place that demonstrated man's inhumanity to man it would be the Bloodlands the areas of Eastern Europe suashed flat two or three times by Hitler and Stalin The author's accounts of casual starvation brutal repression and mass murder w

  3. says: E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder

    E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) First there are numbers 13788 at Polesie23600 at Kamiamets Podilskyi3739 prisoners at Starobilsk358 one night at Palmiry Forest2500 at Leningrad by October 19415500 by November50500 by December1000000 by the end of the Leningrad siege80000 at Stalag 30760000 at Stalag 31955000 at Stalag 32523000 at Stalag 316500000 Soviet prisoners in the General Government450 one night at Krzesawice12000 at Dnipropetrovsk386798 kulaks

  4. says: E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin)

    E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) History As Intention and ResponseHistory can be told in several ways as a textbook like seuence of events and dates; as a moral tale; as a story of the strong or of the weak; from the point of view of the victors or the vanuished; as an account of divine providence or satanic interference Snyder has a particularly engaging method of narrating history as intention and response to circumstances According to his title one

  5. says: characters Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review

    Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review Timothy Snyder’s Bloodlands is about the worst place that ever existed in the world that unfortunate slice of Europe ruled by the two evilest people who ever inhabited our earth Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin Imagine a Venn diagram of evil The left west loop is Hitler; the right east loop in Stalin And in the middle wh

  6. says: characters Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder

    Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) This is history that deserves to be read if for no other reason to acknowledge the individual lives of so many innocent people deliberately murdered We’re not talking war casualties or so called collateral wartime deaths We’re talking civilians sentenced to death by deliberate national policy Sometimes they were targeted because of national political or ethnic reasons Sometimes they were targeted for no particular discernib

  7. says: E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin)

    Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review The history told in Timothy Snyder's Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin is not a revelation Readers familiar with the works of Robert Conuest Daniel Goldhagen Anne Applebaum or Halik Kochanski have read it all before Snyder presents it with a new perspective concentrating on the plight of the minority pe

  8. says: E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review

    E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Having read hundreds of books on World War II it's pretty rare to come across a book which covers a topic I'm not very familiar with However the subject of the Holocaust is one which I've avoided mostly because it's just too damn depressing and while this book covers a broader topic it's probably one I would have skipped in the past I'm glad I didn't skip this oneThe author defines the Bloodlands as the lands between pre war Nazi Germany

  9. says: Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin)

    E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin) Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review Bloodlands The poor beknighted ribbon of land caught between Hitler and Stalin monstrous merciless dictators with their absolutist ideologies and willing apparatchiks Comprising the Baltic states Poland Belorussia and Ukraine fourteen million o

  10. says: E–book (Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin)

    Read ↠ eBook, PDF or Kindle ePUB Ê Timothy Snyder Timothy Snyder Ê 7 review characters Bloodlands Europe Between Hitler and Stalin An account of what happened in the lands between Hitler and Stalin from 1933 to 1952 the year Stalin died These consist of the countries of present day Poland Belarus Ukraine Latvia Lithuania Estonia and the western part of the Russian Federat

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *